If Calories Count, Should You?

By Matt Cardwell
Answer Fitness
What gets measured gets managed – Peter Drucker, management and business icon
Calorie counting.
Outside of the debate over whether there is a “fat burning zone” in cardio, there are few words that spark more passionate debate in the fitness community than whether people should count calories.
The pro-calorie counting camp argues that it’s virtually impossible to make successful changes in a person’s diet without knowing exactly what they are consuming each day. The anti-calorie-counting group counters that counting calories is not only tedious, unnecessary and often-de-motivating, but a surefire path to developing either OCD or an eating disorder.
And like all grand debates, the truth typically lies somewhere in the middle.
Why Calories Matter
If we set aside some of the more esoteric debates around the metabolic differences between certain macro-nutrient combinations, we should all be able to agree at some basic level that calories-in and calories-out is the first place anyone should focus when it comes to cleaning up their diet and losing body fat.
To deny this would require you to basically throw out everything science knows about the conservation of energy and thermodynamics – and basic biology.
So if calorie consumption is at the root of fat gain or fat loss, then calories do matter a great deal.
What Exactly Is Calorie Counting?
When I say “calorie-counting” what I’m really referring to is detailed, daily tracking of food. This usually requires measuring and/or weighing food, whenever that’s possible.
While calorie counting seems to often get associated with weight or fat loss programs, it can also be a powerful tool if you are trying to gain lean body mass, strength or improve athletic performance.
It’s not unusual to fix training plateaus or perform performance in the gym or sports with tweaks to diet. In fact, it’s probably the first place anyone should look when they’ve hit a wall in their progress.
So even if you eat clean and are already very fit, you can benefit every now and then from short-periods of detailed food tracking.
Why Track Your Food?
Tracking your food and calories creates three things:
1. Awareness
2. A Target or Goal
3. A Method for Measuring Progress
Let’s take a look at each one in more detail.
Awareness
Awareness is always the first step in changing or fixing something. If you aren’t aware of a problem, it will persist.
In the case of diet, there are multiple layers of awareness that people need to have in order to make improvements. At the most basic level, you have to understand what you are actually eating. Study after study shows that most people underestimate how much food and how many calories they are actually consuming each day.
Just the act of keeping track of your food for a week or so creates awareness. Forget about whether that food is good or bad. Just learn what it is.
Websites like Sparkpeople, The Daily Plate and FitDay have made it easier than ever for you to log your food. As you do this, you’ll develop a heightened awareness for a number of things:
- Nutritional labeling
- Portions
- How many calories you are actually consuming
- Your own perception gaps between what you think you are eating and what you really are eating
- Macro Nutrients, their ratios and the relative energy/calorie density of things like sugars versus protein.
- Trouble spots in your diet, for instance areas of calorie-density like the two sodas your drinking each day, or the 1,100 calories in that “healthy” vegetarian sub from Blimpie.
Once you have that awareness, it’s actually pretty easy to develop a plan, since you’ll know exactly what you need to work on. But without that awareness and baseline, you’ll be aiming in the dark.
A Target or Goal
One of the biggest benefits of tracking food is that the awareness we just discussed will probably reveal that 80 percent of a person’s improvements to diet will come from making better choices around 20 percent of the foods they are eating.
Create a plan to fix those things and you’ll have a target.
For people who already eat fairly healthy or are trying to optimize their diet for certain athletic or fitness goals, it will be much harder to diagnose areas of improvement without more detailed tracking. If you’ve already ditched all the junk, and you still are hitting a wall, it’s more important then ever to dig down into the details to progress.
Once you identify the worst offenders, you can then start to look at healthy substitutions and make good calculations what you need to eat to hit your fat loss or lean body mass goals.
Again, because most food tracking tools now do all the calculations for you, setting a daily calorie consumption goal is really a cinch. Same goes for tracking and tweaking macro-nutrients.
Continually Measuring Progress
Losing body fat or gaining lean muscle is a slow, gradual process that’s measured in weeks and months, not days or hours.
One of the benefits of tracking food alongside other metrics like % body fat, weight and lean body mass is that it allows you to look back and see your progress, which can be very rewarding and motivating.
It also lets you spot the areas where you continue to struggle and come up with adjustments to fix them. Food tracking gives you visibility into the whys, not just the whats.
Should Everyone Count Calories and Track Food?
In general, I’m a proponent of everyone tracking food and calories for at least an initial period of time when starting a new fitness or diet routine.
Whether a person wants or should to track food the rest of their life is really a matter of how effectively they can align their perceptions to the reality of what they eat.
In most cases, I think an initial round of tracking (generally about 4-6 weeks) is beneficial to nearly everyone, especially people who are just starting to clean up their diet after years of poor eating habits. Awareness is so important in these cases, and it’s difficult to create that awareness without daily accounting and visibility.
How long to continue detailed tracking is really an issue of how easily people are able to “unlearn” their bad habits and adopt the new ones.
It takes about 30 days to break a pattern, so depending on how responsive you are to what you are learning from food tracking, a detailed log might become unnecessary within 4-6 weeks. At that point, your intuition and “feel” for what you are eating may be enough to carry you along.
“Recalibrating” with Calorie Counting and Food Tracking
Once a person has cleaned up their diet, short periods of food tracking (typically 7-10 days) every few months can be useful for checking “portion” creep and “recalibrating” your diet.
Even highly fit people with a very solid sense of portions and knowledge of nutrition can fall victim to portion creep. We live in a super-sized society, and over time, that can start to rub off, distorting our sense of portions.
Going back in and tracking your food for a week can help you spot developing trouble spots and get your portions back on track.
When Calorie Counting Goes Too Far
While some people decide to track calories for the long-haul, this typically isn’t necessary. After a few months, most people should have a pretty solid idea of how they need to eat and in what amounts to support their goals.
Athletes, competitive bodybuilders or figure competitors can benefit from more regular and ongoing food tracking, since more detailed tweaking can be competitively advantageous. However, outside of periods when you have to be in peak condition, ongoing food tracking isn’t typically necessary.
Obsessive or compulsive calorie-counting or food tracking can also be a symptom of more serious underlying issues, like a developing or existing eating disorder. So if you are a trainer, you need to be conscious of how your clients utilize this tool, and be on the lookout for additional signs of possible eating disorders.
Even here, it’s important to remember that food tracking and calorie counting isn’t the cause of this behavior, but typically a symptom of a pre-existing or underlying condition. While it could be reinforcing certain unhealthy behaviors, for most healthy people, it’s not going to cause OCD or eating disorders in people who weren’t already susceptible to them.
Remember, the real goal of calorie-counting and food tracking is to get people to a point where they no longer need to use this tool on an ongoing basis to eat healthy and stay fit. Aside from occasional recalibration periods, long-term food tracking probably won’t be necessary for most people.
For more exercise, diet and fitness tips visit Answer Fitness or follow Matt on Twitter at www.twitter.com/thefitnessnerd

Angie Schumacher is a Certified Fitness Professional who trains clients in her home and is a Women's Boot Camp Instructor in Colorado. She is the author of The Fat Blasting Boot Camp Program and has offered a one stop website to help you with all of your health and fitness needs. Please visit www.BuildingABetterU.com to find exactly what you are looking for!
Popularity: 1% [?]











You make a really good point about recalibrating calorie-intake. To encourage results, you can’t keep doing the same thing or your body will not transform. Very nice!
Jenny DiDonatos last blog post..Tabata Training Method – Ep 32 – Made Fit TV
This is the best article/post on the subject that I’ve seen anywhere — I’ve read quite a bit on the topic. You give a very balanced perspective, which is great. I’m 42 and started my (most recent) diet initiative five months ago. At first, I cut down on food without counting calories or measuring, but after about three weeks, decided I needed it. Calorie King has a fabulous program that made it trivial for me to track my food. That, along with an inexpensive food scale, changed everything. I’m also able to track my exercise, so it’s very motivating to see it on paper. On days where I went way over my goal (e.g., Thanksgiving), I didn’t track the calories. That may seem like a bad idea, but it works for me because I don’t go overboard too often and tracking the calories feels like punishment on those days. In the last couple of weeks, I started pulling back from being overly obsessive about immediately tracking what I eat and taking some chicken off my plate if it says 2.65 oz instead of 2.5 oz. I remind myself that it’s okay — I’ve gotten used to eating the right foods in the right amounts most of the time. I’m still tracking things at the end of the day just to check that I hit what I believed going along I did, but I plan to phase that out eventually as well. I like your idea of doing periodic tracking to keep myself it check. The portions in this country are insane, and it’s easy to start thinking like you’re the one who is crazy. (I went to a restaurant the other day and saw a guacamole appetizer headed to a table that was easily — easily — 3 to 4 cups in sizer. An appetizer.)
Thanks again for the tips and for validating what I’ve learned over the last few months.
I was shocked when I started counting calories. I knew how much was in an apple, orange, and the stuff I bought from the store (since the labels are on the package), but I rarely thought about what I got on the run. Going to Starbuck’s info page blew my mind. Most of the coffee cakes and drinks I was getting were 500+ calories. When I went to the few places that had calories as far as restaurants, I knew that even splitting a meal into two and bringing half home for lunch the next day wasn’t going to work.
Keeping track of the food you eat, and having a pretty good knowledge about how many calories are in it is key to weight loss. If you exercise and say because I exercised I can have X without knowing how many calories you burned or how many you are eating in X, you may be gaining weight instead of losing it!
Great article – thanks for the find Angie!